A few days back, I showed you Julep Ciara, which I love, and mentioned that it reminded me of Orly Galaxy Girl...and I promised you a dupe post about it. The only problem is...I broke the middle finger nail on my dupe hand, and I'm still in that denial phase of nubbin-ness where you only file down your other nails so much because you can't accept that they have to go yet again because this darn nail constantly breaks on you...and so you have those uneven nails while you come to grips with it all...or maybe that's just me, and these pictures will be a sad, tragic tribute to my own neuroses. ::sigh::
What were we talking about? Oh yes. Dupes.
Here are the two polishes in the bottle:
.JPG) |
| Julep Ciara vs. Orly Galaxy Girl |
The shapes of these bottles make this a little hard to interpret. There does seem to be less of the purple edge on the Ciara, but that might just be because of the rectangular shape...So on to the swatches, says I!Here are the two polishes next to one another:
.JPG) |
| Julep Ciara vs. Orly Galaxy Girl |
.JPG)
I have two coats each of Julep Ciara on my index and ring fingers, and Orly Galaxy Girl on Nubby and my pinkie. What's the verdict? Welllll.....I'm gonna go with No Dupe. You can tell a clear difference between the two--Ciara is darker and has more of the blue shimmer. Galaxy Girl is has more of the raisin color showing, and a bit less of the blue showing directly. I qualify it with that crazy 'well' because I think the colors would be a bit closer if Galaxy Girl had three coats...But regardless, that makes them not complete dupes.
Are they similar enough that you don't need both? Sure. You can create similar-enough looks with the two of these, so if you want to avoid things that are too close, you can definitely just grab one of these. Are they different enough to justify buying both? Sure. If you're looking for a justification, I officially just gave it to you. ::wink, wink::
I hope this helps anyone who was wondering about these two, and I apologize for Nubby's cameo appearance!
Hugs and loves,
M.
They're close but I like the Julep better!
ReplyDeleteGood choice! I forgot to put it in there, but in my opinion, the Julep has a slightly better formula, too. :)
DeleteI like Ciara! Haha, I do the same thing when I have a break. I actually broke the nail on my middle finger over the weekend, so it's nubby compared to the rest of the nails too. :)
ReplyDeleteIt's so haaard, isn't it? I sucked it up and filed them down some more today, but they still aren't quite even...sigh...
DeleteMake that 3 preferences for Ciara & I'm usually an Orly girl. LOL
ReplyDeleteOh nooooo's!. I hate it when that happens. Right next to filling the others down for annoyance factor is keeping them filled down while nubbie grows out. At least you still have some free edge & your nail will grow back! <3
It will, 'tis true. But (and I know you know how this is) it's soooo frustrating because I can only do decent free-hand on my right hand, and the index and middle fingers never want to get to a decent length on that hand. I was hoping to have decent length for some holiday designs...oh well. See, this is why I love stamping, I can do it equally well on both hands! :)
DeleteI like Ciara better too, the color looks fresher and the shimmer pops more. When I broke two nails (one on each hand, ugh) I did the same thing and featured two nubs with the rest long because I couldn't bring myself to take them all down. I did it by degrees, so as the nubs were coming up the others were coming down.
ReplyDeleteIt's seriously traumatizing, lol!! I've always hated it, but now that I have a nail blog, it's, it's, it's...it's just sucky!!
DeleteThese are really pretty, I haven't seen this shade before :)
ReplyDelete